Downey et al: Evaluation of long‐term outcome after lung lobectomy for canine non‐neoplastic pulmonary consolidation via thoracoscopic or thoracoscopic‐assisted surgery in 12 dogs
Veterinary Surgery 6, 2023

🔍 Key Findings

  • Thoracoscopic (TL) and thoracoscopic-assisted (TAL) lobectomy were performed in 12 dogs with non-neoplastic pulmonary consolidation.
  • 44% (4/9) of TL cases required conversion, most often due to pleural adhesions or poor visualization — a higher rate than for neoplastic lobectomies.
  • Surgical mortality was 8.3% (1/12 dogs), with death attributed to unaddressed BOAS, not surgical complications.
  • All 11 surviving dogs had no recurrence of clinical signs at a median 24-month follow-up.
  • Perioperative complications occurred in 58% (7/12): pneumothorax (2), hemorrhage (3), wound dehiscence (1), progressive pneumonia (1).
  • One-lung ventilation (OLV) was successful in 78% of TL dogs but may be harder to achieve in brachycephalic breeds.
  • Most dogs had infectious pneumonia (10/12), with bacterial causes identified in 8; fungal and viral etiologies were less common.
  • Hospitalization was short, with median stays of 3–4 days depending on approach and conversion status.

Simini Surgery Review Podcast

How critical is this paper for crushing the Boards?

🚨 Must-know. I’d bet on seeing this.

📚 Useful background, not must-know.

💤 Skip it. Doubt it’ll ever show up.

Thanks for the feedback!
We'll keep fine-tuning the articles vault.
Oops — didn’t go through.
Mind trying that again?

Downey et al: Evaluation of long‐term outcome after lung lobectomy for canine non‐neoplastic pulmonary consolidation via thoracoscopic or thoracoscopic‐assisted surgery in 12 dogs
Veterinary Surgery 6, 2023

🔍 Key Findings

  • Thoracoscopic (TL) and thoracoscopic-assisted (TAL) lobectomy were performed in 12 dogs with non-neoplastic pulmonary consolidation.
  • 44% (4/9) of TL cases required conversion, most often due to pleural adhesions or poor visualization — a higher rate than for neoplastic lobectomies.
  • Surgical mortality was 8.3% (1/12 dogs), with death attributed to unaddressed BOAS, not surgical complications.
  • All 11 surviving dogs had no recurrence of clinical signs at a median 24-month follow-up.
  • Perioperative complications occurred in 58% (7/12): pneumothorax (2), hemorrhage (3), wound dehiscence (1), progressive pneumonia (1).
  • One-lung ventilation (OLV) was successful in 78% of TL dogs but may be harder to achieve in brachycephalic breeds.
  • Most dogs had infectious pneumonia (10/12), with bacterial causes identified in 8; fungal and viral etiologies were less common.
  • Hospitalization was short, with median stays of 3–4 days depending on approach and conversion status.

Simini Surgery Review Podcast

Join Now to Access Key Summaries to more Veterinary Surgery Articles!

Multiple Choice Questions on this study

In Downey 2023 et al., on thoracoscopic lung lobectomy, what histopathologic diagnosis was most commonly associated with resected lung lobes?

A. Neoplasia
B. Pulmonary edema
C. Foreign body granuloma
D. Pneumonia
E. Bronchiectasis

Answer: Pneumonia

Explanation: 10 out of 12 dogs had histopathologic evidence consistent with pneumonia, usually bacterial.
In Downey 2023 et al., on thoracoscopic lung lobectomy, what technical challenge was more frequently encountered in brachycephalic dogs during OLV?

A. Increased bleeding
B. Tube misplacement
C. Failure to achieve one-lung ventilation
D. Unilateral bronchial collapse
E. Airway spasm

Answer: Failure to achieve one-lung ventilation

Explanation: Brachycephalic dogs had more difficulty achieving successful OLV, likely due to airway conformation.
In Downey 2023 et al., on thoracoscopic lung lobectomy, what was the perioperative survival rate for dogs undergoing the procedure?

A. 50%
B. 67%
C. 75%
D. 91.7%
E. 100%

Answer: 91.7%

Explanation: Only one dog did not survive the perioperative period due to dyspnea in a brachycephalic breed.
In Downey 2023 et al., on thoracoscopic lung lobectomy, what was the long-term outcome for dogs that survived the perioperative period?

A. No recurrence in any dog
B. Persistent cough in all dogs
C. 30% recurrence of consolidation
D. Chronic dyspnea requiring oxygen support
E. 50% required reoperation

Answer: No recurrence in any dog

Explanation: All 11 surviving dogs showed no recurrence of disease on follow-up, indicating excellent long-term outcomes.
In Downey 2023 et al., on thoracoscopic lung lobectomy, what was the most common reason for conversion from thoracoscopic to open approach?

A. Poor visualization
B. Failure of one-lung ventilation
C. Severe hemorrhage
D. Pleural adhesions
E. Foreign body migration

Answer: Pleural adhesions

Explanation: The majority of conversions occurred due to adhesions between the lung and pleura, not due to technical failure or hemorrhage.
In Downey 2023 et al., on lung lobectomy for pulmonary consolidation, what percentage of thoracoscopic lung lobectomies (TL) required conversion to open or assisted procedures?

A. 10%
B. 22%
C. 33%
D. 44%
E. 66%

Answer: 44%

Explanation: Four of nine TL procedures required conversion, resulting in a 44% conversion rate.
In Downey 2023 et al., on lung lobectomy for pulmonary consolidation, what was the most common reason for conversion from thoracoscopic to open approach?

A. Intraoperative hemorrhage
B. Failure of one-lung ventilation
C. Surgeon inexperience
D. Pleural adhesions
E. Pneumothorax

Answer: Pleural adhesions

Explanation: Pleural adhesions accounted for 3 of 4 conversions to open thoracotomy.
In Downey 2023 et al., on lung lobectomy for pulmonary consolidation, what was the most common underlying histopathologic diagnosis among dogs undergoing lobectomy for pulmonary consolidation?

A. Bronchioalveolar malformation
B. Bacterial pneumonia
C. Pulmonary edema
D. Fungal pneumonia
E. Cardiac failure

Answer: Bacterial pneumonia

Explanation: Bacterial pneumonia was the primary finding in the majority of dogs (8/12).
In Downey 2023 et al., on lung lobectomy for pulmonary consolidation, what was the most common perioperative complication in dogs undergoing lung lobectomy?

A. Severe hemorrhage
B. Persistent pneumothorax
C. Staple line dehiscence
D. Mild hemorrhage
E. Wound infection

Answer: Mild hemorrhage

Explanation: Mild, self-limiting hemorrhage occurred in 3 of 12 dogs — the most common complication.
In Downey 2023 et al., on lung lobectomy for pulmonary consolidation, what was the median long-term follow-up duration for dogs that survived lobectomy?

A. 6 months
B. 12 months
C. 18 months
D. 24 months
E. 36 months

Answer: 24 months

Explanation: Survivors were followed for a median of 24 months with no recurrence of clinical signs.

Elevate Your Infection Control Protocol

Implement Simini Protect Lavage for superior, clinically-proven post-operative skin antisepsis and reduced infection risk.